I wont lecture you on the presumptions of your question. Nowadays it is common to hear, in mathematics and physics circles, that zenos arguments are based on false assumptions and that no zenolike paradoxes are. Moving moved and will be moving zeno and ngrjuna on motion from mahmudr koan and mathematical physics perspectives. Zenos paradoxes are explained as being the result of inappropriate. Earlier physicists from newton to maxwell had to work much harder to solve their problems. The quantum zeno effect was originally presented in the 1977 paper the zenos paradox in quantum theory journal of mathematical physics, pdf, written by baidyanaith misra and george sudarshan.
It provides an accessible account of most of the current, important mathematical tools required in physics these days. Zeno was a sophist philosopher, and a native of elea, in southern italy. Mathematical solutions of zeno s paradoxes 303 now, 00 is not a well defined expression and is what is known as an indeterminate form. Why mathematical solutions of zenos paradoxes miss the point. Zenos paradoxes are a famous set of thoughtprovoking stories or puzzles. Most mathematical physics textbooks are huge tomes arfken, multiple volume sets courant and hilbert, or both morse and feshbach.
Its considered a standard, though now hard to obtain. Dec 01, 2000 nov 2001 the paradoxes of the philosopher zeno, born approximately 490 bc in southern italy, have puzzled mathematicians, scientists and philosophers for millennia. The answer to whether the standard solution is the correct solution to zenos paradoxes may also depend on whether the best physics of the future that reconciles the theories of quantum mechanics and general relativity will require us to assume spacetime is composed at its most basic level of points, or, instead, of regions or loops or. Those who are nevertheless interested in these topics, nd most physics books to be unaccessible, because of the loose, intuitive and sloppy mathematical language used. Vector algebra is an essential physics tool for describing vector quantities in a compact fashion. Zenos paradoxes are a set of philosophical problems generally thought to have been devised by greek philosopher zeno of elea c. Pederasty in ancient greece was a socially acknowledged relationship between an adult and a. I have given this course several times since 8485, with listeners also from other natural sciences and mathematics. Ive also presented both parts to a highschool math discovery class at much greater length. Zeno constructed them to answer those who thought the idea of parmenides that. The greek philosopher zeno 5th century bce devised several paradoxes of motion that. The paradoxes of zeno have aroused much discussion ever since they were first propounded.
Although none of his work survives today, over 40 paradoxes are attributed to him which appeared in a book he wrote as a defense of the philosophies of his teacher parmenides. Their correct solution, based on recent conclusions in physics associated with time and classical and quantum mechanics, and in particular, of there being a. It is usually assumed, based on platos parmenides 128ad, that. A ccording to it zenos infinite subdivision of a motion is purely mathematical, just an action of. Buddhism, comparative philosophy, mathematical physics. Trish glazebrook, zeno against mathematical physics. Zeno put forward some famous paradoxical arguments against motion. It is usually assumed, based on platos parmenides 128ad, that zeno took on.
Parmenides and zenos paradoxes humanities libertexts. Zenos paradoxes internet encyclopedia of philosophy. Zeno was an eleatic philosopher, a native of elea velia in italy, son of teleutagoras, and the favorite disciple of parmenides. Pdf why mathematical solutions of zenos paradoxes miss the. Zeno against mathematical physics, journal of the history. Mathematical methods in the physical sciences by boas. Acardinalproblem 4 number of parts obtained should at least be dense,inthe mathematical sense of that word. Those who are nevertheless interested in these topics, nd most physics books to be unaccessible, because of the. In rowvector notation, the basis vectors themselves are just i ex 1,0,0 j ey 0,1,0 k ez 0,0,1 1. Achilles and the tortoise paradox and the infinite geometric series. Some of zenos nine surviving paradoxes preserved in aristotles physics and simpliciuss commentary thereon are essentially equivalent to one another. He appears to have resided some time at athens, and is said. Zeno and nagarjuna on motion from mahamudra, koan and.
Zeno of eleas arguments on have not only been an impetus for the most important scientific and mathematical theories in human history, his arguments still serve. Mathematical methods in physics by mathews and walker. Article pdf available december 1996 with 1,115 reads how we. Classical, functional analytic results are put into perspective and compared with more recent ones. Why mathematical solutions of zenos paradoxes miss the. The most famous of these purport to show that motion is impossible by bringing to light apparent or latent contradictions in ordinary assumptions regarding its occurrence. These works resolved the mathematics involving infinite processes.
Reflections on continuity of space and time lead us to banach and tarski and to their celebrated. If one is trying to determine zenos original argument then one should focus instead on analysing the arguments made against zeno by other ancient thinkers. The discussion of integral equations with separable kernels is a perfect example, rather than going on and on with. Zeno against mathematical physics, journal of the history of. David bourget western ontario david chalmers anu, nyu area editors. And further that any resolution to zenos paradoxes, if it is to hit the point, must indeed make metaphysical sense.
Mathematical preparation course before studying physics. Their correct solution, based on recent conclusions in physics associated with time and classical and quantum mechanics, and in. Prologue, free fall and harmonic oscillators, odes and shm, linear algebra, harmonics fourier series, function spaces, complex representations, transform techniques, vector analysis and em waves, oscillations in. We empahsise the complexanalytic structures associated to. The modern science of mechanics starts with newton and galileo. This article follows on from another, more physics orientated. Starting with the notion of vector spaces, the first half of the book develops topics as diverse as algebras, classical orthogonal polynomials, fourier analysis, complex analysis, differential and integral equations, operator theory, and multidimensional. They were created by zeno of elea in the mid5th century bc. This book covers the essentials in a readerfriendly way without pages and pages of exposition. Zenos paradoxes stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. The courses aim to introduce students to some of the mathematical methods and concepts that they will nd useful in their research.
Zeno against mathematical physics 195 easiest to follow when the order in which the paradoxes are presented is ignored and a new order is imposed. Zeno was the son of a certain teleutagoras and the pupil and friend of parmenides. It is probably fairly accurate to say that zenos problems stem from human efforts to comprehend the in. While mathematics can calculate where and when the moving achilles will overtake the tortoise of zeno s paradox, philosophers such as kevin brown and moorcroft claim that mathematics does not address the central point in zeno s argument, and that solving the mathematical issues does not solve every issue the paradoxes raise. We have sought to enliven the material by integrating the mathematics with its applications. Zeno although written nearly a century after zenos death, the primary source of biographical information about zeno is the dialogue of plato called the parmenides. Cambridge university press for the quantity of wellwritten material here, it is surprisingly inexpensive in paperback. The purpose of zeno s arguments on motion from this he thought that he must conclude that the half time must be equal to its double.
This arrangement could of course simply be aristotles. The mathematical models of motion, space and time are merely intellectual constructions built for the convenience of simple calculations, not for the broader purpose of representing the structure of reality. Free mathematical physics books download ebooks online. Therefore in heidelberg the physics faculty has o ered to physics beginners, since many years during the two weeks prior to the start of the rst lectures, a crash course in form of an allday block course. Partial differential equations of mathematical physics pdf 105p this note aims to make students aware of the physical origins of the main partial differential equations of classical mathematical physics, including the fundamental equations of fluid and solid mechanics, thermodynamics, and. We present an overview of the mathematics underlying the quantum zeno effect. In the article, the situation described is a radioactive particle or, as described in the original article, an unstable quantum system. Partial differential equations of mathematical physics pdf 105p this note aims to make students aware of the physical origins of the main partial differential equations of classical mathematical physics, including the fundamental equations of fluid and solid mechanics, thermodynamics, and classical electrodynamics. Methods of mathematical physics volume 1 internet archive.
Philosophers, physicists, and mathematicians have argued over how to answer the questions raised by zenos paradoxes for 25 centuries. The goal of this book is to expose the reader to the indispensable role that mathematicsoften very abstractplays in modern physics. Philosophers, physicists, and mathematicians have argued over how to answer the questions raised by zeno s paradoxes for 25 centuries. Nov 2001 the paradoxes of the philosopher zeno, born approximately 490 bc in southern italy, have puzzled mathematicians, scientists and philosophers for millennia. Apr 01, 2001 zeno against mathematical physics zeno against mathematical physics glazebrook, trish 20010401 00. Zenos one and many relation and parmenides prohibition.
In this article we examine the logic of zeno s paradoxargument against plurality and we show, by analyzing zeno s argument as it appears in simplicius on aristotle physics 9,59,19 and. Mathematical methods for physicists a concise introduction this text is designed for an intermediatelevel, twosemester undergraduate course in mathematical physics. On two occasions, ive presented part i of the below to audiences of moderately technically. More sophisticated in its approach to the subject, but it has some beautiful insights. But ill take the opportunity to address why some people might feel the way you did. Prologue, free fall and harmonic oscillators, odes and shm, linear algebra, harmonics fourier series, function spaces, complex representations, transform techniques, vector analysis and em waves, oscillations in higher dimensions.
This isnt really a math textbook, but math is an extremely important part of physics. Pdf why mathematical solutions of zenos paradoxes miss. Springer at the same level as this text with many of the same topics, but said di erently. Zeno against mathematical physics zeno against mathematical physics glazebrook, trish 20010401 00. Some of zenos nine surviving paradoxes preserved in aristotles physics. In this article we examine the logic of zenos paradoxargument against plurality and we show, by analyzing zenos argument as it appears in simplicius on aristotle physics 9,59,19 and. Following a lead given by russell 1929, 182198, a number of philosophersmost notably grunbaum 1967took up the task of showing how modern mathematics could solve all of zenos paradoxes. This yields some new insights into mathematical preconditions entailing the zeno paradox, in particular a simplified proof of misras and sudarshans theorem.
Pdf on jul 28, 2017, robert alan paul and others published. We may say a thing is at rest when it has not changed its position between now and then, but there is no then in now, so there is no being at rest. Zeno of eleas motion and infinity paradoxes, excluding the stadium, are stated. Reflections on continuity of space and time lead us to banach and tarski and. John wiley publ about the right level and with a very useful selection of topics. The fallacy lies in the claim that when a body moves parallel to one in motion with the same speed as it does move passed one at rest, the time of passing is the same in both cases. We know little 1axiomatic versus constructive procedures in mathematics, the mathematical intelligencer 7 4 1985, 1017. One very recent book that looks extremely interesting is physics for mathematicians. Zenos paradoxes are a set of philosophical problems generally thought to have been devised.
Zeno also argued against the commonsense assumption that there are. Zeno of eleas motion and infinity paradoxes, excluding the stadium, are stated 1, commented on 2, and their historical proposed solutions then discussed 3. Moving moved and will be moving zeno and ngrjuna on motion from mah mudr koan and mathematical physics perspectives. Plato has socrates claim that zeno and parmenides were essentially arguing exactly the same point parmenides 128ab. Budker institute of nuclear physics, 630 090, novosibirsk, russia.
Starting with the notion of vector spaces, the first half of the book develops topics as diverse as algebras, classical orthogonal polynomials, fourier analysis, complex analysis, differential and integral. Applying the mathematical continuum to physical space and time. But it was not until quite recent times that men began to doubt. Against zenos theory of the continuation of time, aristotle argued that if time. To illustrate the relevance of zenos arguments to a discussion of the consequences of special relativity, compare the discussion of time dilation in section 2. Pdf analysis of the logic of zenos argument against. Cambridge university press 1956 acrobat 7 pdf 117 mb. The pdf to word excel powerpoint converter purpose of this book, or possibly series of books, is indicated precisely b. Zeno s paradoxes are a famous set of thoughtprovoking stories or puzzles. The purpose of zenos arguments on motion from this he thought that he must conclude that the half time must be equal to its double. Achilles is to run a race against the tortoise who has a head start.
122 1310 894 77 756 717 1070 722 1395 1378 39 912 1498 265 311 653 1489 570 55 164 767 145 1113 543 93 1018 1257 694 987 992 556 1278